Dripping Faucet: Repair It or Replace It?

What a drip is actually telling you

A faucet drips because the part that is supposed to seal the water off has worn out. In most modern faucets that is a cartridge; in older ones it is a rubber washer or seat. These are inexpensive parts, and replacing them stops the drip without touching the faucet body.

A drip is worth fixing promptly rather than tuning out. A slow drip wastes a surprising amount of water over a year, and the constant moisture wears the seat further and can stain a sink. The sound is annoying, but the waste is the real cost.

When the faucet body itself is sound, this is straightforward faucet repair, and it is almost always cheaper than a new faucet.

When replacement is the smarter spend

Repair stops making sense at a certain point. A new faucet becomes the better value in a few situations: if it leaks around the base rather than the spout, if the finish is corroding, or if the handle is loose and worn. The same is true of a low-end builder-grade unit that has been dripping off and on for years.

The math is simple. Parts and labor to nurse an old faucet along can approach the cost of a solid new one that will not need attention for years. And a builder-grade faucet in a Towne Lake or Eagle Watch house that all went in the same season is often at the same tired stage as its neighbors.

A quality replacement also fixes problems a repair cannot, like a weak or splayed spray, a finish that will not clean up, or a design that was never comfortable to use.

Cartridge availability is a quiet factor in the decision. A quality brand keeps replacement cartridges available for years, so a good faucet is worth repairing. A bargain unit whose parts are no longer made forces a replacement even for a small fault, which is one more reason a decent faucet is cheaper over its life.

The valve under the sink matters more than the faucet

Here is the part most people overlook. Before any faucet work, you need to shut off the water at the angle stop valves under the sink. On an older home those valves often will not turn, because they have sat untouched for years and seized.

A shutoff that will not close is a real problem, because it is your fast way to stop water at that fixture in an emergency. Replacing a seized angle stop with a modern quarter turn valve is a small job that pays off the first time you need to shut the water fast.

We check and replace those valves as part of faucet work, and it is the same get-ahead thinking behind a plumbing maintenance visit. The faucet is the visible part; the valve is the one that saves you later.

There is a comfort factor people forget to weigh. A faucet you use dozens of times a day should feel good to use, and a worn handle, a weak stream, or an awkward reach are reasons enough to replace one that technically still works. Function and feel both count when the fixture is this hands-on.

Installing a new faucet so it lasts

A faucet is only as good as its installation. A new unit needs fresh supply lines rather than the old ones reconnected, a proper seal at the deck so water does not seep under it, and connections that are snug without being overtightened. Skipping the new supply lines is a common shortcut that leads to a call back.

If you have bought a faucet you like, we are glad to install it correctly, and we will flag anything about the sink or valves that needs attention while the cabinet is open. That is often the moment to catch an aging supply line before it fails.

Done right, a new faucet is a fixture you forget about for a decade. Done as a rushed swap, it is a drip or a cabinet leak waiting to happen. The parts are the same; the care is the difference.

Reviewed by the Woodstock GA Plumbing Co team. Work is carried out by licensed plumbers to the Georgia State Minimum Standard Plumbing Code, the state's adaptation of the International Plumbing Code (IPC), and permitted through the City of Woodstock and Cherokee County where the code requires it.

Questions, answered